Hempel, the function of general laws in history, journal of philosophy 1942. However, there have been sharp disagreements about the acceptability of this idea, and even its meaning. Dray s book breaks down into a brief introduction and five intellectually challenging chapters organized around topics that form some of the core debates within philosophy of history. Hegels philosophy of history is perhaps the most fully developed philosophical theory of history that attempts to discover meaning or direction in history 1824a, 1824b, 1857. It is hard to bring under one definition the many philosophical questions and responses that are concerned with history. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. Volumes 15, 19601966 this page contains links to tables of contents and abstracts of articles for issues dated 19601966 volumes 15. Literary form and historical understanding david carr, william dray et al eds. Smelser, theory of collective behavior bernard barber jstor carroll quigley, the evolution of civilizations and feliks koneczny, on the plurality of civilisations jean floud jstor. Pdf versions of quinquennial indexes are available adobe acrobat reader required. In contemporary philosophy a distinction has developed between speculative philosophy of history and critical philosophy of history, now referred to as analytic.
The book attempts to treat both major questions driving much of the. History and theory is the premier international journal in the field of theory and philosophy of history. Dray carefully delineates the difference between critical and speculative philosophy of history, and then explains why his work will concentrate. As with the other instalments in this excellent series, this is a short book approx. History and theory table of contents volumes 15, 19601966. This update of the original version focuses on six central problems in the critical philosophy of history and explores the connections among them.
Collingwood regarding the nature of historical understanding, of charles beard about the possibility of an objective. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Philosophy of history the term philosophy of history probably covers a larger variety of endeavors than similar terms such as philosophy of law or philosophy of science. This article discusses a seminal turn in past philosophy of history with an eye to the practice of historians of philosophy of science.
Dray, philosophical analysis and history philpapers. The controversy as to whether or not historical truth is objective is as old as the profession itself. In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available. Pdf it has recently been argued that the philosophical study of. A history of philosophy volume vii modern philosophy. Alfred stern, philosophy of history and the problem of values henry m. A history of philosophy volume vi modern philosophy. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Image books doubleday new york london toronto sydney auckland. Philosophy of history and history of philosophy of science.
Starting with the fundamentals of each philosophical topic in history and then delving into the specifics of each to better understand the surrounding issues, the reference first offers a comprehensive introduction into these topics then covers. It has been the aim of the translator to present his author to the public in a really english form, even at the cost of a circumlocution which must sometimes do injustice to. Grasp the contribution of philosophy of history to reflections on intercultural understanding. Philippe verreaultjulien 2019 studies in history and philosophy of science part a.
Drays book breaks down into a brief introduction and five intellectually challenging chapters organized around topics that form some of the core debates within philosophy of history. From the postkantian idealists to marx, kierkegaard, and nietzsche frederick copleston, s. Twalsh, in a kind of appendix, has something to say about toynbee. William h dray this update of the original version focuses on six central problems in the critical philosophy of history and explores the connections among them. In the second half of each class, one or two students will present position papers on the reading material.
My use of the term critical philosophy of history derives from dray 1964. Walsh, an introduction to the philosophy of history, 7th impr. Two pieces are published for the first time and the remaining eight are reprinted with at. Dray, narrative versus analysis in history, philosophy of the social. If the philosophy of history is now in a flourishing state in englishspeaking countries and in countries where english is read, this is due in no small measure to the stimulus provided by the writings of r. Dray, not only constructed a series of arguments to demonstrate the deficiencies of the coveringlaw theory but further proposed an alternative conception of rational explanation, whichit was suggestedfitted many of the familiar ways whereby historians seek to render the past. Pdf philosophy of history and theory of history who needs. Philosophy of history, the study either of the historical process and its development or of the methods used by historians to understand their material. It remains the case that there can be few more contentious areas of philosophy than the philosophy of history. General introduction ought not a minister to have, first a good understanding, a clear apprehension, a sound judgment, and a capacity of reasoning. Prenticehall, 1993, introduction, explanation and understanding, historical causes 3, 6288 richard t. Is not some acquaintance with what has been termed the second. William dray, laws and explanation in history philpapers. Especially important discussions were offered by william dray.
In part 1 of this book, originally published in 1980. Pdf philosophy of history and theory of history who. Philosophy of history stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The books have sections or chapters on hegel, except for kant 1963, an important precursor of hegel. Hempel, william dray, karl popper, the role of individuals in history, the ideas. Philosophy of history and history of philosophy of science make for an interesting case ofmutualcontainment. He is known for his version of antipositivist verstehen in history, in laws and explanation in history, and his work on r. The former questions the meaning and purpose of the historical process whereas the latter studies the.
Founded in 1960, history and theory publishes arti. Pdf information organization and the philosophy of history. The term was coined by french philosopher voltaire in contemporary philosophy a distinction has developed between speculative philosophy of history and critical philosophy of history, now referred to as analytic. Featured texts all books all texts latest this just in. History and philosophy in georges canguilhems historical epistemology. William dray and explanation of what in history similarities and differences between explanation in history, social and.
He was professor emeritus at the university of ottawa. Much of the best work that has been done in this field since the posthumous publication in 1946 of his wellknown book the idea of history has been a conscious attempt to. The former questions the meaning and purpose of the historical process whereas the latter studies the foundations and implications of history and the historical method. And dray chooses toynbee and niebuhr as two of his three examples the third one is hegel. History and theory and history and theory, 19601975, in frank ankersmit and hans kellner, a new philosophy of history 1995, 4069. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months.
From the french enlightenment to kant frederick copleston, s. Pdf the idea of a philosophy of history researchgate. Hegel regards history as an intelligible process moving towards a specific conditionthe realization of human freedom. The term was coined by french philosopher voltaire. The series is aimed at readers interested in the philosophy of the arts, crosscultural. Walsh, dray and others built philosophy of history anew as an understanding of historical practice rather than of historical progress. Sibree and published under a creative commons license by our open media. Certainly, philosophers should not engage in unfounded and. Selected readings in philosophy of history, packet of photocopies ii. Links to the fulltext versions in the jstor archive are provided as well. William herbert dray 23 june 1921, in montreal 6 august 2009, in toronto was a canadian philosopher of history. The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. Philosophy of history since 1900 history is philosophy teaching.
Sshort but excellent work in the new prenticehall series in philosophy attempts to survey the two majorareasusually subsumed under philosophy of history. This book aims to advance the critical discussion in three ways. Disclaimer all of the graphics and some of the text have been reproduced from the works referenced without citation. Given the plurality of voices within the philosophy of history, it is impossible. Featured texts all books all texts latest this just in smithsonian libraries fedlink us genealogy lincoln collection. Bibliography in philosophy of history 11272005 date reference 1766 voltaire, francoismarie arouet. Chimisso 2003 studies in history and philosophy of science part c. In part 1 of this book, originally published in 1980, the focus is on certain claims of r. A pdf version of this book is available for free in open science at.
Demonstrate an enhanced ability to research independently on the issues taught. Draysownposition is closer to that of hempel a positivist. Dray, narrative versus analysis in history, philosophy of the social sciences 15 1985. The theor y of historical inq u ir y 3 history as a discipline with an intellectual personality of its own. The concept of speculative philosophy of history the concept of speculative philosophy of history gruner, rolf 19721001 00.
History and theory and history and theory, 19601975, in frank ankersmit and hans kellner, a. William dray perspectives on history world of digitals. Philosophy of history is the philosophical study of history and its discipline. Dray, philosophy of history, englewood cliffs, 1964, p. Dray was here paraphrasing another philosophers argument. The selections for each class must be thoroughly read, and everyone should be prepared to discuss the material. The graphics have been taken from donald palmers looking at philosophy. Dray, not only constructed a series of arguments to demonstrate the deficiencies of the coveringlaw theory but further proposed an alternative conception of rational explanation, whichit was suggestedfitted many of the familiar ways whereby historians seek to render the past intelligible. These works are by notable authors on the general topic of the philosophy of history. It has been the aim of the translator to present his author to the public in a really english form, even at the cost of a circumlocution which must sometimes do injustice to the merits of the original.
Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences 34 2. Explanation and understanding representative of the former group, w. Information organization and the philosophy of history article pdf available in journal of the american society for information science and technology 646. Starting with the fundamentals of each philosophical. Philosophy of history and culture presents original works broadly concerned with philosophical treatments of the ideas of culture and history, culturally and historically embodied entities, and with interpretive strategies pertinent to their understanding. Walshs philosophy of history walsh 1960 1951, first published in 1951 and revised in 1960, is an openminded and well grounded effort to provide an indepth presentation of the field that crosses the separation between continental and analytical philosophy. Dray, 9780128164, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
718 290 839 1176 1056 30 1303 753 1192 1022 219 955 1268 1385 392 207 1313 1005 826 6 1332 389 211 1177 650 204 536 404 614 302 9 63 771